1. Kenny Payne, Louisville (2022–2024)
- Overall Record: 12–52 (.188)
- Conference Record: 5–35 ACC (.125)
- NCAA Tournament Appearances: 0
Of all the coaches on this list, Kenny Payne is probably the easiest choice for No. 1. Winning just 12 of 64 games at a program with three national championships, a massive fan base, and some of the best resources in college basketball is pretty hard to top.
And the crazy part? Payne was supposed to be the guy who brought Louisville basketball back.
A member of the Cardinals' 1986 national championship team and a longtime assistant under John Calipari at Kentucky, Payne returned to his alma mater in 2022 to plenty of excitement. That didn't last long.
Louisville opened his first season with three consecutive one-point home losses to Bellarmine, Wright State, and Appalachian State. The Cardinals eventually started 0–9 and finished 4–28, setting a school record for losses.
Surely Year 2 couldn't be as bad, right?
Well, Louisville lost a preseason exhibition to Division II Kentucky Wesleyan, then went 8–24, including losses to Chattanooga, Arkansas State, and a DePaul team that entered their matchup at 1–7.
Across his two seasons, Payne's teams suffered 33 double-digit losses, went an almost unbelievable 1–28 away from home, and finished dead last in the ACC both years.
By the end, fans had largely checked out. Despite playing in a 22,000-seat arena, Louisville averaged just 6,504 scanned tickets across Payne's 35 home games.
The university fired him in March 2024, eventually agreeing to a $7.25 million separation payment.
And to put the whole thing in perspective, Payne's replacement, Pat Kelsey, won 27 games and earned an NCAA Tournament bid in his very first season, more than doubling Payne's two-year win total.